Workplace Bullying Measurements And Metrics To Use In The Nhs-Books Pdf

Workplace bullying measurements and metrics to use in the NHS
09 Nov 2019 | 3.6K views | 12 downloads | 58 Pages | 1.05 MB

Share Pdf : Workplace Bullying Measurements And Metrics To Use In The Nhs

Download and Preview : Workplace Bullying Measurements And Metrics To Use In The Nhs

Report CopyRight/DMCA Form For : Workplace Bullying Measurements And Metrics To Use In The Nhs



Transcription

Foreword
The aim of this report is to identify how workplace bullying can be tracked over time
to indicate what measures and metrics can be used to identify change and to
provide comparators for other sectors in the UK and internationally
Bullying can encompass a range of different behaviours Deciding on a definition of
workplace bullying can clarify what is regarded as bullying but it may also narrow
the focus and exclude relevant issues of concern For example bullying definitions
typically state that negative behaviours should be experienced persistently over a
period of time The threshold for behaviours to be defined as bullying could be set
to include one or two negative acts per month over the previous six months or more
stringently to include only behaviours that occur at least weekly over the previous
twelve months Choosing an appropriate threshold for frequency and duration of
behaviours raises several questions should occasional negative behaviours be
regarded as bullying Would one or two serious episodes of negative behaviour be
regarded as bullying Some researchers use the criteria of weekly negative
behaviours over six months to identify bullying but others argue that occasional
exposure to negative acts can act as a significant stressor at work Zapf et al 2011
We have identified a range of tools and metrics that can be used to track change
over time However there are a number of important issues to consider when
measuring bullying which may affect the interpretation of the results In particular
bullying prevalence rates vary considerably depending on the type of metric and
definition of bullying used For example one international review found prevalence
rates ranging from less than 1 for weekly bullying in the last six months up to 87
for occasional bullying over a whole career Zapf et al 2011
There are three main types of direct measures of bullying self labelling without a
definition self labelling with a definition and the behavioural experience method
Self labelling metrics typically ask a respondent to identify themselves as a target of
bullying e g Have you been bullied at work with a yes no response or How
often have you been bullied at work with a frequency scale such as
never occasionally monthly weekly daily This approach is quick and easy to
administer but is more subjective as responses will be based on the respondent s
interpretation of bullying This approach can be improved with the provision of a
definition of bullying and a request to use the definition when responding However
following pilot work Fevre et al 2011 argued that respondents tended not to read
and digest bullying definitions as they had already decided what bullying meant to
them
The behavioural experience method offers a more objective approach but is typically
longer and more time consuming This method involves respondents rating the
frequency with which they have experienced different negative behaviours e g
How often has someone humiliated or belittled you in front of others with a
frequency scale such as never now and then monthly weekly daily These
behavioural inventories may not mention bullying but capture the prevalence of
2
specific negative acts and a total score may be calculated The threshold for the
frequency and number of negative acts or a total score required for an experience
to be regarded as bullying can be chosen by the researcher Although this enhances
the objectivity of the measure it may be that the respondent themselves may not
regard their experience as bullying
In a meta analysis of bullying studies conducted across 24 countries Nielsen et al
2010 found an overall prevalence rate of 18 1 for self labelling with no definition
11 3 for self labelling with a definition and 14 8 using a behavioural experience
checklist For best practice it is recommended that both the self labelling with a
definition and the behavioural experience method are used in bullying research Zapf
et al 2011
It is also important to be specific about the type of bullying being measured In
particular if the measure is designed to capture bullying at work between co workers
this should be explicitly stated so that bullying from patients and their relatives is
excluded
Interpretation of the results may also be somewhat complex Although increases in
bullying prevalence should undoubtedly be addressed we need to be mindful that an
increase in reported bullying may reflect a change in culture changing expectations
of the behaviour of colleagues and managers or a move towards greater openness
and willingness to address concerns that were previously ignored or condoned A
measure of employees trust in the organisation to respond appropriately to such
allegations may act as a positive indicator
The perceived and actual anonymity of responses is a critical factor Employees are
understandably wary about providing sensitive information on bullying and have
voiced concerns regarding being identified and the potential repercussions of
reporting bullying Carter et al 2013 There is a considerable discrepancy between
the prevalence of bullying as captured in anonymous questionnaires and direct
reports of bullying made to the organisation e g to managers or HR Scott
Blanshard Child 2008 Protecting the anonymity of respondents and ensuring
that individuals cannot be identified will be important factors in the administration of
a bullying measure
Some metrics are already routinely collected by the NHS and if examined closely
could provide useful indicators of change Direct indicators include complaints about
bullying and responses to ongoing NHS staff surveys Indirect metrics can be used
to capture factors that are associated with bullying such as psychological wellbeing
including stress anxiety and depression sickness rates job satisfaction and
organisational commitment However factors other than bullying will affect these
measures The prevalence of witnessed bullying could also be considered as an
important metric A large proportion of NHS staff report that they have witnessed
bullying between staff and this is associated with negative outcomes for individuals
and teams Carter et al 2013
Comparing the NHS prevalence rates with other sectors in the UK and internationally
is complex Ideally comparators would have used the same definition measurement
3
method and reporting period but the definitions and metrics often differ Total
populations are the ideal but are rarely provided Single site studies are less
generalisable than multi site studies and total samples are preferred over open
invitations to unknown populations which may be more likely to attract responses
from those who have experienced bullying
This report begins with several definitions of bullying describes direct and indirect
measures of bullying and compares the prevalence of bullying in the NHS to other
sectors in the UK and to the healthcare sector internationally
4
Contents
1 Definitions of workplace bullying 6
2 Direct Measures 6
2 1 Formal complaints about bullying 7
2 2 The Negative Acts Questionnaire Revised NAQ R and Short Negative Acts Questionnaire
S NAQ 8
2 3 Bullying Risk Assessment Tool BRAT Hoel and Giga 2006 11
2 4 Quine workplace bullying questionnaire 12
2 5 Obstetrics and Gynaecology questionnaire Adapted from Quine 13
2 6 NHS Staff Survey 14
2 7 General Medical Council GMC National Training Survey NTS 16
2 8 Trade Unions Professional Bodies and Charitable Organisations 20
2 9 Witnessing bullying 22
3 Indirect Measures 23
3 1 General Health Questionnaire GHQ 23
3 2 Sickness and absence levels 24
3 3 HSE Stress Management Standards Indicator Tool 26
3 4 Exit interviews 27
3 5 Other measures 28
3 Workplace bullying in the UK Comparison of Public Private and Voluntary Sectors 29
4 Workplace bullying internationally comparators with UK health service 37
5 Summary and Discussion 41
6 References 44
7 Appendices 49
5

. specific negative acts and a total score may be calculated The threshold for the frequency and number of negative acts or a total score required for an experience to be regarded as bullying can be chosen by the researcher Although this enhances the objectivity of the measure it may be that the respondent themselves may not

Related Books

Report on the Proceedings of the International Conference

Report on the Proceedings of the International Conference

2 Report on the Proceedings of the International Conference on Responsible Research in Education and Management and its Impact development of products systems services and policies Such an approach will demonstrate that social justice equity and sustainability have been considered in line with the needs of all relevant actors Objectives 1

UN COSYST ME POUR UNE FINANCE RESPONSABLE

UN COSYST ME POUR UNE FINANCE RESPONSABLE

Remerciements Ce document a t r dig par Genesis Analytics le partenaire pour l apprentissage dans le cadre du Programme pour une finance responsable gr ce au leadership local et l apprentissage Responsible Finance through Local Leadership

REPORT OF THE REYKJAVIK CONFERENCE ON RESPONSIBLE

REPORT OF THE REYKJAVIK CONFERENCE ON RESPONSIBLE

Report of the Reykjavik Conference on Responsible Fisheries in the Marine Ecosystem Reykjavik Iceland 1 4 October 2001 Rapport de la Conf rence de Reykjavik sur une p che responsable dans l cosyst me marin Reykjavik Islande 1 4 octobre 2001 Informe de la Conferencia de Reykjavik sobre la Pesca Responsable en el Ecosistema

Conference Report Responsible Investor

Conference Report Responsible Investor

RobecoSAM Forum 2016 Conference Report November 2016 The RobecoSAM Forum 2016 focused on demonstrating the impact of long term investing across the sustainabil ity value chain composed of asset owners investment managers corporations and society Sustainable investing is nothing new announced

CONFERENCE REPORT Re thinking Media Responsible Reporting

CONFERENCE REPORT Re thinking Media Responsible Reporting

Responsible Reporting on Humanitarian Crises held as part of the TRT World Forum 2017 The views themes and discussion points expressed in this conference report are those of speakers and participants present at the TRT World Forum 2017 and do not reflect the official view of TRT World Research Centre CONFERENCE REPORT 2017 Re thinking

COMMA WorksheetCloud

COMMA WorksheetCloud

A comma must appear before opening the inverted commas The kids were always full of delight ful surprises Example The party contin ued until midnight and then every body went home Activity Example 37 thirty seven 80 eighty 1 73 2 55 3 22 4 49 5 81 6 19 Write the correct hyphenation line break for each word below Remember to include a hyphen 1 planning 2 telephone 3 pre

Samsung Galaxy A50 A505U User Manual Verizon Wireless

Samsung Galaxy A50 A505U User Manual Verizon Wireless

messaging phone calls receiving notifications screen mirroring and sharing multimedia files See Mobile continuity on page 31 Dark mode Use a darker theme to keep your eyes comfortable at night See Dark mode on page 121 Security Use biometrics to unlock your device See Flexible security on page 29 Expandable storage Expand storage with a supported microSD card See

Sage ERP Solutions I

Sage ERP Solutions I

Sage ERP Solutions Finance Is not as Strategic as it Could Be The notion of involving finance in the development of business strategy is hardly a new one During the 1990s in a search for new ways to create value many companies diversified into areas they did not understand or overpaid for acquisitions that made little strategic sense In the aftermath many companies began looking to

QAD Enterprise Applications Solution Guide July 14 2016

QAD Enterprise Applications Solution Guide July 14 2016

QAD Solution Guide V 34 July 14 2016 Page 1 of 121 QAD Enterprise Applications Solution Guide July 14 2016

Enterprise Resource Planning ERP

Enterprise Resource Planning ERP

Enterprise Resource Planning ERP In order to achieve business growth your organisation needs to run at peak productivity and you need to be able to identify an d rectify inefficiencies quickly and easily Find out how our cost effective and flexible ERP solutions can help Please find in this document the following 3 Technical Overview Product Brochures to help you in achieving this success

T DESIGN FILMMAKING BOOSTER WEEK

T DESIGN FILMMAKING BOOSTER WEEK

Make and break secret codes using math and logic Students learn the historical evolution of cryptography in a hands on exploration of real world codes includ ing Caesar ciphers substitution ciphers Vigen re ciphers affine ciphers and RSA encryption As a final project students develop their own cryptosystem