The Politics Of History In West Papua Indonesia Conflict-Books Pdf

The politics of history in West Papua Indonesia conflict
03 Mar 2020 | 25 views | 0 downloads | 20 Pages | 1.43 MB

Share Pdf : The Politics Of History In West Papua Indonesia Conflict

Download and Preview : The Politics Of History In West Papua Indonesia Conflict

Report CopyRight/DMCA Form For : The Politics Of History In West Papua Indonesia Conflict


ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 2018,VOL 26 NO 1 141 159. https doi org 10 1080 02185377 2018 1445535, The politics of history in West Papua Indonesia conflict. Nino Viartasiwi, The Institute of International Relations and Area Studies Ritsumeikan University Kyoto Japan. ABSTRACT KEYWORDS, This study examines how history is used as a source of legitimacy Indonesia West Papua. and a political instrument in the sectarian conflict between the History Independence. Indonesian government and the West Papua nationalists This Conflict Democracy. paper explores the debate surrounding two historical aspects. relevant to West Papua s demand for independence first West. New Guinea s past as part of the Dutch colony and its relations. with Indonesia and second the 1969 referendum the so called. Act of Free Choice to decide West Papua s fate The Indonesian. democratization in 1998 provided momentum to revise the. narration of West Papua s history Democracy has empowered. the Papuans as the victims of a power struggle to challenge the. previous Indonesia s monolithic narration of history The Papuans. alternative narration of history also serves as a medium of. liberation from oppression by the Indonesian government The. Papuan story counters the theory that the narration of history is a. privilege of the ruler and the winner,Introduction.
History played a substantial role in Indonesian politics during Suharto s regime which. lasted from 1966 to 1998 because the narration of history was systematically arranged. to uphold the power 1 The importance of historical narrative in a political struggle is. perhaps can be referred to Eric Hobsbawm s 1994 view on invented tradition that. show the role of history in the construction of identity and nationalism Hobsbawm. study on the making of The Second German Empire points out how history despite it. is being socially engineered and invented is notable in unifying the people under one. nation and legitimate the state formation The process involves the invention of a. national symbol and the promotion of national historical experiences Then ceremonials. and monuments are created to nurture the nationalist feeling Indonesia s experience sup. ports the postulate in which the ruler constructed and offered a single version of historical. narrative under the pretext of keeping the unity of the nation. In the conflict between West Papua and Indonesia history also has been used as a. means to justify actions and demands 2 This study defines conflict as disagreements. between West Papuan nationalists and Indonesia over the political status of West. Papua based on historical perspectives of each party It is important to note however. that history is one among four other sources of conflict of West Papua and Indonesia. CONTACT Nino Viartasiwi viartasiwinino gmail com, 2018 Informa UK Limited trading as Taylor Francis Group. 142 N VIARTASIWI, as suggested by a study by Widjojo ed 2009 3 During the period from 1945 to 1962. Indonesia was involved in a dispute with the Netherlands the former colonial ruler. about territorial rights to West New Guinea The dispute ended after Indonesia won. the 1969 West Papua referendum with support from the international community. During the period between 1969 and 1998 Indonesia s historical account of West. Papua went unchallenged even though Papuan politicians believed Indonesia s claim on. West New Guinea was extortionate The Papuan politicians claimed that Papua wanted. to be and was an independent country In the post Suharto era the separatist wish. that had been suppressed by the authoritarian regime was rearticulated and the liberation. movement in West Papua was revived To legitimate their demand for the political right to. secede the Papuans offered new narratives of their history A Papuan freedom fighter. Alua 2002a defines the occurrence as the Papua Spring 4. This paper aims to explore how the narration of history has served as an instrument in. the political struggle of West Papua by investigating how history was constructed and. developed by opposing parties The study finds that democracy has made it possible for. the weaker party to offer counterarguments to the ruler s monolithic narration of history. Problematic history of West Papua, Two main issues of history were challenged by the West Papuan nationalists first the. history of West Papua as part of the Netherlands colony and its relations with Indonesia. and second the history of the 1969 referendum known as the Act of Free Choice AFC. The first issue revolves around two claims The first refers to the cultural and racial differ. ences between the indigenous Papuans and the majority Indonesians The second is the. political claim that West Papua was an intrinsic part of the Netherlands East Indies the. embryo of Indonesia These debates were founded on the status of West Papua during. the Netherlands colonial period they focused on whether West Papua was regarded as. part of the Netherlands East Indies or whether it was considered a distinct entity. The second issue is based on the claim by Papuan nationalists that West Papua declared. its independence in 1961 making Indonesia s rule of West Papua and the AFC illegal The. AFC was recommended by the United Nations based on an agreement between the Neth. erlands and Indonesia on the fate of West New Guinea namely the New York Agreement. of 1962 5 The Papuans argued that the New York Agreement was illegal because it. excluded the subject of the dispute from the negotiations. Indonesian government narratives, The Indonesian government is very careful in navigating debates about the history of West. Papua and Indonesia Because choices of diction influence the tone of any report the. Indonesian government usually uses terms such as restoration to define the process by. which Papua officially became part of Indonesia For example such terminology appeared. in a report by the Permanent Mission of the Republic of Indonesia to the United Nations. in 2001 Moreover studies by Indonesian government affiliated historians use phrases. such as kembalinya ke pangkuan ibu pertiwi coming back of the Papuans to the. motherland to define the formal acknowledgment of West Papua as part of Indonesia. In contrast West Papuan observers typically choose words such as incorporation or. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 143, colonization as evidenced in writings by Peter King 2002 2004 These variations in.
diction imply that for the Indonesian government West Papua was returned to Indonesia. post 1969 whereas for many observers West Papua has been an object of domination. Indonesia s perspective on West Papua consists of the following points First Indone. sian territory is based on the Netherlands East Indies territory Indonesia insists West. Papua was a legal and intrinsic part of the Netherlands East Indies and had a long histori. cal connection to seventeenth century Tidore Kingdom Indonesia argues that different. racial characteristics between majority Indonesians and the Papuans should not prevent. the union of people as one nation state Second the struggle of the Papuans to resists. the Netherlands power is a proof of Indonesian nationalism among the Papuans Third. the Papuans had decided to be with Indonesia through a political referendum in 1969. The tale of the Netherlands east indies, As the basis of its claim on West Papua Indonesia holds to the international principle of. uti pesseditis jurist that confirmed the territories of emerging post colonial countries. would follow their pre sovereign territories Indonesia argues that in the Netherlands con. stitution West Papua had always been regarded as part of the Netherlands East Indies. Nederlandsch Indie and had never been identified as a separate entity or a self govern. ing territory Pemerintah Indonesia 1950 Indonesia also points out that the consti. tutions of the Netherlands East Indies namely the Indische Regerings Reglementen of. 1854 and de Indische Staatssregeling of 1925 stated that the governor general s territory. covered all territories of the Netherlands East Indies and never excluded West Papua. Yamin 1956 1958 Soebandrio 2001 pp 7 8 argues that West Irian had been part. of the Netherlands Indies since 1828 under the border agreement of Meridian 141 and. the acknowledgment of the Tidore Kingdom s territory 6 Furthermore according to Sub. andrio 2001 the political history of Indonesia in West Papua was also proven with the. exile of thousands of Indonesian nationalists to Boven Digul Tanah Merah and Merauke. in the 1920s because the Netherlands would only exile the prisoners within its territories 7. Additionally President Sukarno believed the Papuans harboured Indonesian national. ist feelings as a result of being contacted by and acculturated with Indonesian political. prisoners in exile Departemen Penerangan Republik Indonesia 1962 Patiara 1984. Pemerintah Indonesia 1950 Sjahrir 1968 Soekarno 1961 Soewarsono 2013 Yamin. 1956 Moreover Indonesian historians claim that local uprisings that occurred between. 1939 and 1943 to resist the Dutch and the Japanese in Manokwari and Tanah Merah. were tokens of pro Indonesia movements Bachtiar 1963 Pemerintah Indonesia. 1950 8 The uprising in Biak was labelled Koreri 9 Sociologically speaking however the. Koreri related more to the cargo cult sentiment than to the struggle for Indonesia s inde. pendence Kamma 1955 and Penders 2002 argue the movements were reactions to. harsh treatment by the Dutch the Japanese and their subordinates. On the racial differences between the Papuans and Indonesians Mohammad Yamin. 1956 1958 argues that racial characteristics should not be a burden because Indonesia. was built by hundreds of different ethnic groups and various racial groups which was. also the case in the formation of the Netherlands Kingdom More recently Indonesian. arguments in opposition to the notion of the racial distinction of the Papuans as a key. component of West Papua s bid for independence have relied on historical materials. 144 N VIARTASIWI, regarding the relationship of the region with Java and the Majapahit kingdom as well as its. connections with Ternate and Tidore Indonesia argues that the Netherlands representa. tive admitted before the UN Security Council in 1948 that the diversity of Indonesia was a. product of common Netherlands sovereignty this argument was reinforced by a Nether. lands report to the United Nations in 1949 that said Racially the indigenous peoples may. be broadly divided into Malays in the West and Papuans in the East As these races have to. a considerable extent intermixed they are not separated by clearly defined boundaries. Permanent Mission of the Republic of Indonesia to the United Nations 2001 Thus. Indonesia argues that racial homogeneity should not be used to claim the political unity. of a community,The Indonesian West Papuan, Indonesian historiography records Papuans uprisings in the 1940s as a struggle for Indo. nesian independence Indonesia proclaimed independence on 17 August 1945 but the. Netherlands did not deliver sovereignty to its former colony until December 1949. During the intervening years the Netherlands tried to maintain control of the Netherlands. East Indies by proposing through many conferences that Indonesia become a federal or. union state In the conferences the Netherlands introduced the concept of a federal. state of Indonesia to the eastern regions of the former Netherlands East Indies without. adding West New Guinea to the plan The Netherlands insisted on retaining West New. Guinea by claiming that the Papuans had different racial characteristics than the majority. of Indonesians The Netherlands also was encouraged by statements from the Indonesian. statesman Mohammad Hatta who repeatedly argued in favour of excluding West New. Guinea from Indonesia because of the racial distinction of the Papuans 10. The first conference the Malino Conference was held in South Sulawesi and was. intended to negotiate the idea of the United States of Indonesia comprising four. federal states Djawa Sumatera Kalimantan and Timur Besar Great Eastern The Neth. erlands administration in New Guinea appointed a Papuan Biak Frans Kaisiepo to rep. resent West New Guinea The Netherlands expected that Kaisiepo would oppose. Indonesia based on his experience as a Netherlands employee At the conference. however Kaisiepo declared that the Papuans wanted to work with Indonesia and the. Netherlands Interestingly one day before the Malino conference on 15 July 1946 the. Netherlands formally established West New Guinea as an autonomous residence karesi. denan separated from its former parent entity Maluku West New Guinea was a ward. afdeling of the Maluku residency Indonesian territory until 1944 after the Pacific. war 11 West New Guinea was only identified as a residency several years later through. Decree No 180 dated in July 1949 Then West New Guinea officially became an indepen. dent province of the Netherlands in a decree dated 29 December 1949 12 Sinaga 2013 and. Koentjaraningrat and Bachtiar 1963 argue that the instalment of an autonomous resi. dence highlighted the region as an independent political entity in the future territorial. The second conference the Pangkalpinang Conference was held in October 1946 and. was attended by representatives from minority communities i e Arabs Chinese and. Dutch descendants In the conference Indonesian Dutch descendants proposed. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 145, autonomous status for West New Guinea under the Netherlands kingdom with the objec. tive to secure the region as the colony of the Indonesian Dutch people. In December 1946 the third conference the Denpasar Conference was held At the. Denpasar Conference representatives from Kalimantan and Great Eastern were invited. but representatives from West New Guinea were left out Delegates from other regions. objected the exclusion of West New Guinea by releasing a motion to affirm West. Papua Irian as an integral part of Indonesia 13 The motion which gained 68 out of 70 del. egations votes was the first dispute over the status of West Papua The participants of the. conference finally agreed on a new federal state namely the state of Eastern Indonesia. on 24 December 1946 The newly established state thereafter was always involved in dis. putes with the Netherlands over the status of West Papua According to Drooglever. Schouten and Lohanda 1999 the Netherlands decision to exclude West Papua from. the proposed Great Eastern State was due to political reasons the decision was intended. to emphasize that the region as not part of the Federal Republic of United States of Indo. nesia Indonesia argues that the demand of Papuan representatives at the Malino confer. ence and the Netherlands efforts to suspend Papuan representatives from attending other. conferences are evidence of Indonesian nationalism amongst Papuans Bachtiar 1963. Sinaga 2013, In the mid 1940s political parties thrived in West Papua In Biak the Peoples Voice.
Political Party which aimed to promote the people s welfare and expel the Netherlands. was established by Lukas Rumkorem in September 1945 Meteray 2012 Rumkorem. also founded an organization named the Union of Indonesian Independence PIM in. retaliation the Netherlands imprisoned him from 1947 to 1949 In 1949 Rumkorem reac. tivated the PIM in Bosnik alongside Corinus Krey the vice chair Rumkorem was again. imprisoned this time at Hollandia Prison which was 500 kilometres away from Biak. He was then moved farther away to Digul Prison where he stayed until 1957 Penders. 2002 notes that after Rumkorem was imprisoned political movement in Biak essentially. In Hollandia on 16 November 1946 a female Indonesian doctor J Gerungan and. Papuan activists Corinus Krey Petrus Wettebossy and Marthen Indey established the. Committee for Indonesian Independence KIM It was amid this enthusiasm for political. movements that the Netherlands held the Denpasar Conference which excluded Papuan. representatives in December 1946 In protest KIM members Marthen Indey Corinus. Krey and Nicolaas Jouwe published a letter addressed to the Netherlands This letter. dated 13 December 1946 made two important points first Papua should be incorporated. into the Indonesian federation by what was previously known as the Netherlands Indies. second the Netherlands decision not to invite Papuan representatives to the conference in. Bali should be rejected Meteray 2012, During the same period political movements also erupted in Serui On 28 November. 1946 Silas Papare Baldus Dumatubun Benjamin Kajai and Barnabas Aninam sup. ported by Sam Ratulangi an Indonesian politician and the exiled Governor of Sulawesi. established the Indonesian Independence Party of Irian PKII PKII also was backed. by groups from different races and religions such as the Tionghoa Chinese association. at Serui which was led by Yakop Thung Tjing Ek The PKII spread in Sorong in the 1950s. and Silas Papare soon became an influential figure in the Indonesian struggle for West. 146 N VIARTASIWI, Papua 14 Papare was adamant that West Papua was historically a part of Indonesia because. Indonesia consists of numerous races and religions Meteray 2012. In Fakfak in March 1948 Raja Rumagesang Al Alam Ugar Sekar the raja of Kokas. ordered his people to lower the Netherlands flag This action prompted the Kokas. people to clash with the Netherlands forces The Netherlands punished Raja Rumagesang. with a life sentence and exiled him to Makassar Prison at Sulawesi Island Sinaga. Syukur 2013, The struggles to unite West Papua to Indonesia continued in the 1950s For instance. Abraham Koromat established the Indonesian Youth Association Sangaji Malan formed. Perintis and Bastian Samori created the Irian Youth Organization In the late 1950s Galim. Raesa and Ismael Bauw established the Revolutionary Movement of West Irian in Fakfak. to support the Indonesian government In Biak 1958 Lukas Rumkorem who had just. been freed from the Netherlands prison established the Tjendrawasih Reserves Army. TTT 15 The TTT soon spread in other areas and helped the Indonesian government. gather photos and information about the Netherlands vital military installations in. West Papua Tarumaselly in Meteray 2012, Indonesia believes that Papuans were among the participants of a milestone event in. Indonesian history the Youth Pledge Sumpah Pemuda which occurred on 28. October 1928 16 Ramses Ohee a chieftain from Waena Jayapura and a voter in the. AFC claims that his father Abner Poreu Ohee was one of the Papuan youths attending. the Youth Pledge Kompas 2009 Abner Ohee was a prominent Papuan from Tobati. Enggros of Waena Another Papuan who was claimed to have attended the Youth. Pledge was Aitai Karubaba from the Ambai village of Serui The two Papuans supposedly. joined Jong Ambon Moluccans youths because West New Guinea was part of the Tidore. Sultanate at the moment These claims support the previous statements made by Papuan. student organizations in 1963 1964 in support of the Youth Pledge Interestingly Singh. 2008 p 97 argues that these statements were a product of special intelligence operations. led by General Ali Murtopo who created students movements in Yogyakarta and Jakarta. to show Papuan youths support for Indonesia, Indonesia has been persistent in the claim that West Papua is undeniably an integral.
part of the Republic of Indonesia because the region was also the part of the Netherlands. East Indies Therefore the struggles between 1945 and 1969 are portrayed as efforts to free. its territory from the colonizer Indonesia believes that the political developments in West. Papuan nationalism in the 1960s were a game played by the Netherlands to retain its. power in West Papua On 19 December 1961 therefore President Sukarno declared an. action to seize West Papua this decision was termed the Three People s Commands. Trikora 17 To uphold Trikora Indonesian military prepared the Mandala Command. to attack West Papua and take it over by 17 August 1962 The initial military operations. were executed however the primary attack was delayed and then called off following a. series of negotiations that resulted in the New York Agreement. Indonesia s arguments on the act of free choice, The Indonesian government is aware of the protest over the execution of the 1969 refer. endum and its result The representative consultation system of voting through the so. called Consultative Assembly has become one of the points subject to accusations of. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 147, fraudulence by Papuan nationalists The result that showed 100 of voters were in favour. of Indonesia was also criticized In an official document released in 2001 the government. of Indonesia finally replied to the inquiry over the West Papua issues through the Perma. nent Mission of the Republic of Indonesia to the United Nations. Indonesia argues that the United Nations which observed the process through UN Sec. retary General UNSG representative Ortiz Sanz supported the implementation of the. AFC The document highlights that Ambassador Ortiz Sanz gave his approval for the. musyawarah method of the AFC after engaging in discussions with the Indonesians. and travelling all over the region to communicate with the people Indonesia s argument. for the voting arrangement was that in the 1960s the particular socio cultural condition of. the Papuans and the geographic difficulties presented an enormous challenge to a one. man one vote voting system, Moreover Indonesian claims that consultations with the representative councils during. the election of members of the Consultative Assembly and the AFC were also attended by. the UNSG representative team The UNSG representatives also participated in all the Con. sultative Assembly sessions for the AFC Indonesia further notes that the Netherlands was. kept informed of the arrangements and policies made by Indonesia to execute the AFC. Indonesia points out that on 20 21 May 1969 at the request of the Netherlands govern. ment the Foreign Ministers of Indonesia and the Netherlands met in Rome The Rome. meeting resulted in a joint statement of approval from the Netherlands government for. the musyawarah method of the AFC as the best procedure for practical and technical. reasons Furthermore Indonesia claims that it instituted the necessary arrangements to. guarantee the AFC s implementation by the New York Agreement and the wish of the. Papuans One of the provisions issued on 25 March 1969 by Indonesia s Minister for. Home Affairs was Decree No 31 which stipulated that the Council for the AFC. members had to be native Papuans and that they had to be elected democratically follow. ing the aspirations and traditional values of the Papuans Indonesia argues that these. undertakings provide definitive proof that the AFC was a valid exercise of political self. determination, With regards to the result of the referendum in which all representatives decided to. remain united within the Republic of Indonesia Indonesia states that the result was. expected because the government had been overwhelmed by support from the Papuans. before the referendum The government claims that it received well documented petitions. from the Papuans between 1962 and 1968 showing their strong commitment to be a part. of Indonesia and their view of the AFC as unnecessary 18 Subandrio the then Indonesian. Foreign Minister also noted that members of Papuan political parties visited Jakarta to. submit their petitions in support of integration with Indonesia without a plebiscite. Drooglever 2010 Also Indonesia has stressed that the referendum was carried out. peacefully without violence of any kind which indicated there was no serious. disagreement, The international reaction after the AFC has been used as evidence of widespread rec.
ognition for Indonesia s good deed After the referendum Indonesia and the UN Special. Representative separately submitted reports to the Secretary General who annexed the. two reports in a final report to the United Nations General Assembly on the fulfillment. of the second stage of the New York Agreement The report concluded that an act of. free choice has taken place in Papua in accordance with Indonesian practice in which. 148 N VIARTASIWI, the representatives of the population have expressed their wish to remain with Indonesia. United Nations Secretary General 1969 p 2 United Nations Peacekeeping n d Indo. nesia notes that the Netherlands did not challenge the result of the AFC Subsequently. Indonesia the Netherlands Belgium Luxembourg Thailand and Malaysia co sponsored. a draft of a General Assembly resolution Finally the General Assembly adopted the draft. as resolution number 2504 XXIV on 19 November 1969 by a vote of 84 to none with 30. abstentions The General Assembly accepted the report of the Secretary General and. appreciated the fulfillment of the tasks assigned to the UN Secretariat General For Indo. nesia the United Nations Resolution 2504 XXIV was a further gesture of the affirmation. of the result of the AFC and the final conclusion to the question of West Papua Indonesia. argues that the adoption of the resolution by the General Assembly indicates that the inter. national community at that time fully formally and irrevocably recognized West Papua as. a part of Indonesian territory Embassy of the Republic of Indonesia in London United. Kingdom 2011 Furthermore because the Charter of the United Nations Article 10. also guaranteed the validity of the AFC the AFC is viewed as a valid law in Indonesia. The Papuans contested narration of history, During the Suharto era Indonesia was privileged with unchallenged historical narration. The Papuans did not have enough of a platform to voice their account of history not only. because of the scarcity of historical documentations but also because of the Suharto. regime s iron glove treatment of the Papuans The regime answered political and cultural. movements with severe punishments or assassinations as happened in the case of Arnold. After Indonesia started to democratize its political system the Papuans had the oppor. tunity to present their own account of history The raise of democrats as presidents. namely President Habibie 1998 1999 and President Abdurrahman Wahid 1999. 2001 made space for Papuans to articulate their political concerns Papuans were. allowed to express their political aspiration without fearing of state s persecution Encour. aged by Indonesian government s spirit to uphold democracy by opening the freedom of. expression in 1998 the Papuan leaders quickly consolidated political movements and. offered counter narrations of the established history Indigenous Papuan writers. thrived advocating West Papuan political movements The first public upheaval to intro. duce Papuans version of history was a political gathering the Second Papuan People s. Congress which occurred 29 May 4 June 2000 and was attended by thousands of indigen. ous people from all over the region Because history is central to the Papuans struggle the. main theme of the event was rectifying the history of West Papua 20 One victory of the. political movement was the return to the name West Papua from the Indonesian name. Irian Jaya, The Papuans suffered a setback in their exercise of freedom of expression during the. Megawati presidency which lasted from 2001 to 2004 The aggravation culminated in. the murder of Theys Hiyo Eluay by Indonesian Special Forces in 2001 the imprisonment. of Benny Wenda in 2002 and politically motivated communal clashes during this time. period After 2004 during Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono s administration the government. took a democratic approach to the West Papua problem As hope rekindled Papuan. writers and politicians again began offering their interpretations of Papuan history. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 149, Democracy has empowered the Papuans to dare to raise their political aspirations Indi. genous leaders religious leaders politicians and students in big cities were the front line of. the movement while the society at large followed behind the leadership Political articu. lations however remained exclusive to the Papuan elites as they were resourceful. Majority of the members of Papuan society who are also poor were unaware of their pol. itical rights due to the lack of education Nevertheless re narration of history by the. Papuans can be seen as an initial step to be peremptory in politics. On a nation named West Papua, The notion of West Papua as a nation finds its root in the racial characteristic of the.
Papuan people and the region s political development Other reasons for Papuan nation. alism include dissimilarities in ethnology biology language geography and history with. The notion of racial difference as a reason to secede was at the heart of the Papuan. Spring The Papuan writer Mandowen 2005 p 28 states Historically Papuans have. always been ethnically different from the Asian based population of Indonesia Wonda. 2009 pp 20 23 writes that even though Papuans have ethnic similarities with some. groups in Indonesia the people of West Papua are entirely different from Indonesian s. ethnic majority thus Papuans are never admitted as part of Indonesian because physically. they are not same as they ethnic Malay people Wonda also highlights that trying to Indo. nesianise the Papuans who are physically and culturally different is equal with obfuscat. ing the true identity of the Papuans Most West Papuan indigenous communities practise. Melanesian culture as proven by governmental features such as big man leadership com. munity level decision making and small close knit communities that do not answer to a. higher authority Tribalism is a central component of Papuan socio political organization. thus Papuan cultures vary amongst each other The claim of distinctiveness in race and. culture is documented in a manuscript of the Papuan political event termed the Great. Consultation which took place in 2000 21, Historians have conducted studies on the connection of some parts of West Papua with. Maluku kingdoms of the sixteenth century The kingdoms Tidore Bacan and Ternate. were also connected with the Netherlands government as vassals to both the Netherlands. and the VOC Vereenigde Oost Indische Compagnie that is The Dutch East Indian. Company To contest the historical documentation of Tidore Kingdom s rule over. parts of West Papua in the sixteenth nineteenth centuries Papuan nationalists highlight. the colonial context of that period Papuan scholar Benni Giay points out that Ternate and. Tidore s rule over West Papua was colonialism rather than a nation state experience. because Papuans suffered and were oppressed Giay in Alua 2002b p 59 Mandowen. 2005 argues that it was a historical accident because the Netherlands ruled West. Papua through the Sultan of Tidore for practical administrative reasons Therefore. because the relationship was essentially exploitative in nature the Papuans did not experi. ence nationhood under the Maluku kingdoms rule on West Papua. An additional argument in favour of identifying West Papua as a separate entity from. Indonesia is the absence of Papuan youths at the Indonesian Youth Pledge on 28 October. 1928 The Papuans believe their representatives were absent from the event The Papua. People s Congress 2000 decided that because Papuans were not involved in the Indonesian. 150 N VIARTASIWI, Youth Pledge West Papua was not part of the territory of the Republic of Indonesia Alua. 2000 According to Thaha Al Hamid a West Papuan leader the absence of Papuan youth. at the Youth Pledge indicated that Indonesian nationalism was built without the partici. pation of the Papuans 22 Moses Werror the chief of the Revolutionary Council of Free. Papua Organisation shares this opinion 23, Nevertheless the main argument for West Papuan nationalism is the proclamation of. West Papua as a sovereign state In his opening speech at the Papua People s Congress. 2000 Theys Hiyo Eluay the leader of the highest body of the Papuans the Papua Presi. dium Council claimed that West Papua had declared sovereignty on 1 December 1961. Eluay argued that Indonesia had robbed West Papua s sovereignty through the Trikora. and the AFC Furthermore Eluay insisted that Papua had never been culturally and pol. itically integrated with Indonesia because Papua never had a historical connection with. Indonesia and never lived with Indonesia Alua 2000 pp 38 39. Eluay s views resonate with the arguments of many Papuan nationalists in terms of. their political demands since the Papuan Spring West Papuan writers such as Alua. 2000 2002a 2002b 2002c Karoba 2004 Mandowen 2005 Wonda 2009 Peyon. 2010 and Yoman 2010 2012 share these ideas explicitly or implicitly Wonda. 2009 p 30 argues that the world needs to recognize that West Papua s sovereignty. was established acknowledged and active during the Netherlands Kingdom period. named Nieuw Guinea Raad and had both the Morning Star flag and the national. anthem Hai Tanahku Papua Leaders of West Papuan armed groups such as Lambert. Pekikir24 and Goliat Tabuni or political leaders such as Benny Wenda and Buchtar. Tabuni also insist that West Papua achieved independence in 1961 BBC Indonesia. 2014 International Crisis Group 2011 Particularly the notion of a deliberate twisting. of the history of West Papua s incorporation into Indonesia is shared by ordinary. people such as a man named Om Imbi whom I met at a Manokwari beach during field. work on 15 April 2014 Imbi believes the Dutch the Indonesians and the international. community tricked the Papuans with the New York agreement by leaving Papuan repre. sentatives out from negotiations processes making a decision on West Papua without the. people s consent and ignoring West Papua s claim of sovereignty Imbi s chronological. description of the international events is surprising given that he is an ordinary person. who spends his time on Manokwari beaches and greeting strangers This same vision of. West Papua s history and sovereignty can be found amongst the ordinary Papuan s ordin. ary people regarding West Papua s history and sovereignty can also be found at Kirksey s. study 2012 pp 34 37,The problem of the AFC, West Papuan nationalists such as Mandowen 2005 and Yoman 2010 argue that West. Papua was ready to claim sovereignty with the help of the Netherlands in the early 1960s. The political development culminated on 1 December 1961 which was marked with a cer. emony and a political manifesto During the early 1960s Papuan political parties were. established in many afdeling administrative regions in preparation for establishing the. New Guinea Council In April 1961 the West New Guinea Council was inaugurated as. the political representation of the Papuans Albeit 13 out of the council s 29 members. were appointed by the Netherlands government and only in Manokwari and Hollandia. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 151, was direct voting conducted the establishment of the body was seen as a proof of Papuans.
ability to practise democracy During this time West Papua already had a thin layer of. ambtenar government officers and intellectuals from the indigenous people The New. Guinea Council then established another political institution the New Guinea National. Committee which had around 70 80 elected members The committee submitted a pol. itical manifesto to the Dutch governor Plateel, On 1 December 1961 a ceremony was held to announce the New Guinea National. Committee s political manifesto The ceremony was held in front of the New Guinea. Council s office in Hollandia and was attended by Governor Plateel and followed by. Papuans in all afdelings in West New Guinea That day all Papuans working in schools. or governmental offices were given a day off to join the festivities In the ceremony. New Guinea s name was changed to West Papua The West Papua flag flew side by. side with the Netherlands flag for the first time although it was allowed to fly only in. public spaces and not in government offices After singing the Netherlands national. anthem the Papuan students choir sang the Papua national anthem Points of the political. manifesto were as follows first West Papua is the chosen name of the West New Guinea. second the nation is called West Papua third the Morning Star flag is the flag of West. Papua fourth Hai Tanahku Papua is the national anthem. Papuan nationalists have argued that a proclamation of independence took place that. day Alua 2006 p 43 writes On 1 December 1961 with the approval of the Netherlands. royal government the Papuan National Committee declared the independence of West. Papua in Hollandia Similarly Willy Mandowen the appointed mediator of the. Papuan People s Congress 2000 stated on 4 July 2000 in front of President Abdurrahman. Wahid that a sovereign state was established on 1 December 1961 Alua 2000 Interest. ingly Fritz Kirihio a Papuan politician in the 1960s acknowledged that this date was not. in fact a proclamation of independence Chauvel 2005 pp 17 18 However many post. 2000 Papuan nationalists believe West Papua announced its proclamation of indepen. dence on that day Consequently the AFC of 1969 is viewed as erroneous because it. denied the existence of the sovereign state of West Papua and the preceding negotiations. were conducted secretly without addressing the concerns of the Papuans. The AFC was a political consequence of the New York Agreement that was signed at. the headquarters of the United Nations on 15 August 1962 and it became the United. Nations Treaty Series 1962 No 6311 Critical points of the agreement were as follows. First the Netherlands New Guinea would be transferred to United Nations Temporary. Executive Authority UNTEA and would be passed to Indonesia by 1 May 1963. Second Indonesia with advice assistance and participation from the UN representatives. would arrange the AFC for the inhabitants of West Papua Third the referendum to. honour the right of self determination would be completed before the end of 1969. After the exercise of the right of self determination Indonesia and the UN representatives. would submit final reports to the UN Secretary General who would report to the General. Assembly United Nations 1962, West Papuan nationalists not only perceive the AFC as illegal but they also are. infuriated by its execution in 1969 The implementation of the AFC was problematic. because the voting system did not follow democratic principles The common inter. national voting practice is a one man one vote system in which every eligible adult. under agreed category has a right to vote The structure used in the AFC was a. 152 N VIARTASIWI, musyawarah consultation system in which the vote was conducted by representatives of. the people who were chosen by a committee from selected groups 25 The main challenge. the practice of the musyawarah system in the AFC is the potential for foul play in the. execution of the system because both the representatives and the committee responsible. for choosing those representatives were handpicked by Indonesia Another argument is. that at the national level Indonesia had already practised direct election in its two prior. elections thus the nation should have supported similar conduct in West Papua The. third argument is that the one man one vote system had been used in two cities in. West Papua Manokwari and Hollandia to choose the New Guinea Council members. in 1961 even though other areas were using the representative mechanism Therefore. Papuans should have been ready to implement the one man one vote system in other. places in West Papua, Benny Wenda the leader of Free West Papua and a spokesman for the United Liber. ation Movement of West Papua ULMWP argues that it is Indonesia s claim that Papua. is a part of Indonesia but for us the Papuan people and nation we do not recognize such. an Indonesian claim because according to international law the decision was not based on. one man one vote BBC Indonesia 2014 Buchtar Tabuni the leader of the National. Parliament of West Papua PNWP shares Wenda s opinion Tabuni claims that the. one man one vote system was exercised in 1960 during the election of the New Guinea. Council Papua Post n d, The Papuans accounts of history however mostly based on opinions and interpret.
ations of events that lack adequate empirical evidence Although personal history. cannot be discounted a shared experience by the people presents a more powerful argu. ment Also the lack of Papuan intellectuals and writers who support the Papuans perspec. tive of history create repetitiveness in the narration of the history As a result the Papuan. alternative history becomes no less monolithic than Indonesian version of history Finally. more Papuan scholarships and investigations into past events regarding the history of the. relationship between West Papua and Indonesia are critical to helping the Papua case. The justice by historians, By examining the VOC and Netherlands colonial archives historians such as Goodman. 2002 2006 and Cribb and Kahin 2012 have proven the validity of the claim that. West Papua is an integral part of the Netherlands East Indies Furthermore scholarly pub. lications in the 1930s and 1940s also regarded Dutch New Guinea as part of the Nether. lands East Indies Vlekke 1943 p xi in his study of the history of Nusantara a forerunner. of Indonesia states that the Netherlands East Indies consisted of areas from the western. point of Sumatra to the Dutch Australian boundary in New Guinea In his account of. Japanese occupation in Indonesia in the 1940s Vlekke 1943 p 408 wrote that the. enemy never succeeded in completing the conquest of Indies In Merauke capital of the. district of South West New Guinea the Dutch flag was still flying when these lines. were written well guarded by soldiers of the Netherlands Indies and of the United. States Army Furnivall 1939 clearly states that the Netherlands India comprised five. larger islands with New Guinea as the largest island Since these books were published. before Indonesian independence and the dispute over West Papua started the notion. that New Guinea was once part of the Netherlands East Indies is undeniable. ASIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE 153, Studies on the AFC on the contrary have empowered the Papuans counter narration. of history Drooglever 2010 and Saltford 2003 2008 have conducted studies on the. AFC agreement and its implementation Drooglever 2010 sees the execution of the. AFC as marred by manipulation and tricks intended to gain the results favoured by the. organizer The study criticizes the Netherlands and the United Nations for the unfairness. of the referendum One of the criticisms is based on the wording of the UN Secretary. General U Thant s report before the General Assembly that says an act of free choice. has taken place in Papua Drooglever suggests that the use of the word an instead of. the in the report indicates that for the Secretary General a referendum had taken. place but because of the low standard of the referendum the more definite convincing. word the could not be applied, Saltford s 2003 study is based on materials from the UN Archives in New York. British and Australian National Archives and US and Netherlands government. records Saltford provides a study of how the 1962 New York Agreement was. applied with particular emphasis on the role of the UN Saltford s aim is not to ques. tion the legitimacy of the West Papuans right to self determination which was guar. anteed by the Netherlands and Indonesia through the New York Agreement and the. responsibility for ensuring that these rights were properly upheld fell to the UN Sec. retariat Rather Saltford argues that the UN Secretariat s priority in the implementation. of the AFC was to make West Papua legally recognized as a part of Indonesia with. minimal controversy and disruption as recommended to the UN by Washington in. 1962 The New York Agreement guaranteed Papuans political and human rights. specifically the right of full self determination In the implementation however. Papuans rights were ignored through the poor performance of UNTEA and the UN. Secretary s representatives Saltford 2003 p 184 remarks that if the UN s motive in. 1962 with the New York Agreement was to prevent a damaging war between the Neth. erlands and Indonesia there was no similar danger in 1969 that could justify the UN s. tolerance of misconduct in the implementation of the AFC. Conclusion, This study highlights the political process of forming an historical narration to legiti. mate a claim and shows that Indonesia received greater support than did the Papuans. West Papua was the victim of a large political game played from the 1940s to the. 1990s In the political struggles between the world s two political poles the wishes of. the Papuans did not matter Nevertheless the efforts of the Papuans to deliver their. account of history in the 2000s proves that the narration of history no longer. belongs solely to the powerful Democracy has allowed the weaker parties to present. their sides of history Although the new narration of the history of the Papuans. might be problematic because of a lack of evidence and also monolithic in its own. account it is nevertheless clear that the reinterpretation of history also serves as a. medium of liberation from oppression Equally important for West Papua s keen obser. vers it is now evident that an understanding of West Papua s conflict rooted in its. history is also a friction itself because of the variations in the elucidation of that. history In the end the starting point for studying the West Papua conflict may be. determined by which version of history is accepted. 154 N VIARTASIWI, 1 Suharto was the President of the Republic of Indonesia from 1966 to 1998 and used violence.
and oppression to consolidate and sustain his authoritarian regime The backbones of Suhar. to s power were the military the union of the state s civil servants a political party named. Golongan Karya and industrialists enticed through crony capitalism Suharto resigned. from the presidency following political turmoil and economic crisis in 1998. 2 The study uses the term West Papua to refer to a region now formally known as Papua that. consists of West Papua Province and Papua Province The region was alternately known as. West New Guinea West Nieuw Guinea Netherland Nieuw Guinea and West Papua during. the Dutch colonial period The region was called West Irian or Irian Jaya by Indonesia during. the period from 1945 to 2000, 3 Those are the history of integration status and political identity political violence and. human rights abuse the failure of development and Special Autonomy Status policy incon. sistency and marginalization to the indigenous, 4 Alua 2002a highlights the term Papua Spring to address Papua s post 1998 movements. He argues that the post 1998 political struggle had different characteristics than previous. struggles in 1961 and 1965 The new struggle was characterized by some new values it. was based on people s power in rural cities involved all elements of the people and exercised. peaceful and democratic behaviours, 5 The New York Agreement was a deal reached between Indonesia and the Netherlands to. resolve the dispute over the status of West New Guinea after a series of negotiations mediated. by the United States and authorized by the United Nations Indonesia and the Netherlands. had disputed the status of West New Guinea since 1949 On 2 January 1962 the Netherlands. agreed to negotiate with Indonesia The initial negotiation failed however because the two. parties could not find common ground the Netherlands demanded that the West Papuans. rights be central to the talk whereas Indonesia required a transfer of power as the basis of. negotiation In April 1962 a US diplomat Ellsworth Bunker presented the so called. Bunker proposal The plan was first offered in a secret ambassadorial level meeting in Mid. dleburg Virginia in March 1962 and went through a series of negotiations before finally. being agreed upon by both parties On 15 August 1962 an agreement based on the. Bunker Proposal namely the New York Agreement was signed at the headquarters of the. United Nations in New York, 6 On 28 August 1828 the Netherlands East Indies government established a post named Fort. du Bus in the southern coastal area of West Papua The post was held as a token of the Neth. erlands power over the western part of New Guinea with the 141st meridian east of Green. wich as the border The border was set based on Tidore s authority In the post s opening. ceremony which corresponded with the birthday of the king Commissaries van Delden. read a proclamation in the name of King Willem I After the ceremony the kings of Nama. totte Sendawan and Lakahia Kassa as well as the Orang Kaja big man of Lobo and. Mawara Lutu signed an agreement of cooperation and accepted silver headed sticks as a. symbol of their power in their respected areas The Dutch considered the agreement to be. a recognition of the Netherlands power, 7 The Indonesian political prisoners exiled at Boven Digul Tanah Merah and Merauke in New.
Guinea from 1927 to 1942 were known as Digoelists, 8 When World War II ended West Papua was still very much underdeveloped Most parts of. the region especially in the Central Highlands had come into contact with the outside world. only four or five years prior to the war During the Japanese occupation 1942 1944 edu. cation health facilities food supplies from outside regions and religious services were. banned The Japanese also forced the Papuans along with around 1700 forced workers. from Java to work in military facilities in West New Guinea Japan employed the Amberi. Maluku people and a few Dutch educated Papuans to work in clerical and security jobs. 9 Koreri is a messianic or cargo cult movement practiced by the Biak people a leading tribe in. West Papua The movement was initially practised as a tradition of the Biak people but.

Related Books

Spiritual Care Resources for Religious Holidays

Spiritual Care Resources for Religious Holidays

Spiritual Care Resources for . Religious Holidays (Passover, Easter, & Ramadan) During the . COVID-19 Pandemic . Traditional religious practices during high holy days in the Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions as well as resources for those who are spiritual but not religious . Ylisse C. Bess, MDiv., Chaplain . Shelly Rambo, Associate Professor of Theology, Boston University . UPDATED 4

DELHI COLLEGE OF ARTS & COMMERCE (University of Delhi ...


DELHI COLLEGE OF ARTS & COMMERCE (University of Delhi) Netaji Nagar, New Delhi-110023 TIME TABLE ... Personal Selling BCP/Sem-VI R -66 DSE-4 Consumer Protection/OB BCP/Sem R-66 Tut DSE-4 Consumer ... COLLEGE OF ARTS & COMMERCE (University of Delhi) : COMMERCE ...

Inversion of Neural Networks: A Solution to the Problems ...

Inversion of Neural Networks A Solution to the Problems

Corp. has been modeled as a neural network. This paper shows how inverting this network and providing it with a given output/hot metal temperature produces the required inputs/amount of the inputs to the blast furnace which are needed to have that output. Inverting neural networks produces a one to many mapping so the problem must be modeled as an optimization problem, which needs to be ...

Traffic Management Study -

Traffic Management Study urbantransport kar gov in

traffic management study sadashivanagar and bellary road directorate of urban land transport june 2013

The Collected Works of Eric Voegelin, Volume 18: Order and ...

The Collected Works of Eric Voegelin Volume 18 Order and

of Eric Voegelin, Volume 18: Order and History, Volume V, In Search of Order Ellis Sandoz, Editor University of Missouri Press. the collected works of ERICVOEGELIN VOLUME 18 ORDERANDHISTORY VOLUME V INSEARCHOFORDER. projected volumes in the collected works 1. OntheFormoftheAmericanMind 2. RaceandState 3. TheHistoryoftheRaceIdea:FromRaytoCarus 4. TheAuthoritarianState ...

Friday, September 28, 2018 Beals set to unveil improvements

Friday September 28 2018 Beals set to unveil improvements

on $1.5 million in improve-ments which have been made to the century-old building over the past year and a half. The work brings Beals into com-pliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, includ-ing the installation of a new entrance, an elevator that runs from basement to the second floor, and handicap accessible bathrooms.

Linux Pocket Reference For System Administrators

Linux Pocket Reference For System Administrators

year 2000. Since then Linux takes away major portion of his day. He has been teaching O and A level students of Cambridge University in Pakistan since 1998. He has also served as an instructor to graduate and post-graduate level in different institutes in Islamabad, such as Preston University and Petroman Training Institute, for the subjects as: Software Engineering, C/C++, Data Structures ...

FOOT/PRINT - COnnecting REpositories

FOOT PRINT COnnecting REpositories

3. Magazine Life Cycle Assessments 3.1 Time and InStyle 3.2 The Green Press Initiative 3.3 Backpacker 3.4 Discover 3.5 National Geographic 3.6 Findings for the Magazine Industry 4. Strategies, Challenges, and Controversies 4.1 Certified Paper 4.2 Low-Carbon Paper Production 4.3 Recycled Paper 4.4 Other Paper Strategies 4.5 Public Education 4.6 ...

Developing Leader Character - HRPA

Developing Leader Character HRPA

Leaders and HR professionals need these tools if they are ... Handbook of virtue ethics in business and management. Springer. ... Title of Presentation

[MS-THCH]: Tracing HTTP Correlation Header Protocol

 MS THCH Tracing HTTP Correlation Header Protocol

The Tracing HTTP Correlation Header Protocol specifies the E2EActivity HTTP header which can be used by an HTTP/1.1 client to communicate a unique identifier for an HTTP message to an HTTP server.